Roofing Materials Comparison: Which Material is Best for Your Edmonton Home?
When it’s time to replace your roof, choosing the right roofing material can feel overwhelming. With so many options available - from asphalt shingles to rubber, steel, and standing seam metal - homeowners want to know which product offers the best balance of durability, warranty, and value.
At Weatherproof Roofing, we believe in educating our customers with clear comparisons so you can make the best decision for your home and budget. Below, we compare roofing materials that we install across Edmonton and the surrounding area to help you make an informed decision.
Quality Asphalt Shingles: Affordable & Reliable
IKO Cambridge and IKO Dynasty are two of the most popular asphalt options. Both carry a Limited Lifetime Warranty and offer strong wind ratings of up to 130 mph. Dynasty shingles stand out with their ArmourZone nailing strip, which makes installation easier and helps ensure long-term performance.
GAF Timberline HDZ offers an unlimited wind warranty when installed as a system, plus a lifetime algae resistance guarantee (StainGuard Plus). Meanwhile, Owens Corning Duration shingles feature the SureNail strip, designed for precision installation and added holding power.
Approximate Cost per Square (CAD): $330–$360
Best for: Homeowners looking for cost-effective, reliable roofing with good warranty coverage.
Premium Asphalt Shingles: Stronger, Longer-Lasting
For those who want the durability of asphalt with enhanced performance, Malarkey Vista and Malarkey Legacy shingles are excellent upgrades. Both are made with SBS-modified asphalt (rubberized), giving them greater flexibility, impact resistance, and longevity. They also feature Lifetime Algae Resistance and a Class 4 impact rating, making them a strong choice in Edmonton’s hail-prone climate.
Approximate Cost per Square (CAD): $400–$500
Best for: Homeowners who want high-performance shingles with strong sustainability benefits (each roof diverts ~5 rubber tires and ~3,200 plastic bags from landfills).
Rubber Roofing: Sustainable & Impact-Resistant
Euroshield Rubber Roofing is manufactured from 95% recycled tires and plastics, offering unmatched sustainability and a Class 4 impact rating. With a wind rating of 160+ mph and a Limited Lifetime Warranty, it’s an ideal choice for Edmonton homeowners who want extreme durability and eco-friendly materials.
Approximate Cost per Square (CAD): $900
Best for: Homeowners seeking sustainable, long-term roofing solutions that resist hail and harsh weather.
Stone-Coated Steel Roofing: Elegant & Durable
Decra Stone-Coated Steel roofing combines the strength of Galvalume steel with a stone finish for a natural look. When asking what roofing material lasts the longest, homeowners are happy to discover that it has a Class 4 impact rating, 50-year transferable warranty, and excellent sustainability since it’s fully recyclable.
Approximate Cost per Square (CAD): $1,200
Best for: Homeowners who want a premium, long-lasting roof with a traditional appearance.
Standing Seam Metal Roofing: Top-Tier Performance
FormaLoc 16” Standing Seam Metal Roofing offers one of the highest wind ratings (150–180+ mph) and durability that lasts 40–50 years. With hidden fasteners and non-organic material, it resists algae growth entirely. While installation requires highly specialized crews, the result is one of the most durable and modern-looking roofs available.
Approximate Cost per Square (CAD): $1,200
Best for: Homeowners wanting a sleek, modern look with industry-leading durability and performance.
Weatherproof Roofing Helps You Choose the Best Roof for Houses in Your Area
Every home is unique, and the right roofing material depends on your budget, design preferences, and long-term goals. Whether you’re deciding between a standing seam metal roof vs. asphalt shingles or simply wondering, what is the best roofing material for my home, we can help. At Weatherproof Roofing, we guide you through the different types of roof materials, provide photo documentation for full transparency, and back every installation with warranties you can trust.
Call 780-394-5744 today to schedule your free estimate and let us help you find the perfect roofing solution for your Edmonton home.